Emotional Affairs: What They Are, Why They Hurt, and How to Rebuild Trust

Emotional Affairs: What They Are, Why They Hurt, and How to Rebuild Trust

Emotional affairs can quietly unravel a relationship from the inside out. As a Gottman-trained relationship therapist, I often support couples grappling with the pain and confusion that comes when emotional boundaries are crossed—even when there’s no physical betrayal.

What Is an Emotional Affair?

An emotional affair happens when one partner forms a deep connection outside the relationship that begins to replace emotional intimacy within the relationship.

It may start as a friendship or work connection, but over time emotional closeness builds, secrets are kept, and energy is drawn away from the partnership.

Common signs include:

• Sharing personal feelings or life details with someone else more than your partner
• Keeping the relationship secret or downplaying its importance
• Feeling emotionally excited or validated by the other person
• Turning to them for comfort or support instead of your partner
• Withdrawing emotionally or sexually from your relationship

Why Emotional Affairs Are So Hurtful

The damage from an emotional affair is often about what was lost in the primary relationship—trust, safety, emotional closeness—not just what happened outside it.

For the betrayed partner, the pain comes from:

• Feeling emotionally abandoned or replaced
• Losing trust in their partner’s honesty or loyalty
• Confusion and self-doubt
• The secrecy and deception that often accompany emotional affairs

Can You Rebuild Trust After an Emotional Affair?

Yes. While it takes time, trust can be rebuilt with honesty, empathy, and consistent action. The Gottman Method shows us that trust is formed not in grand gestures, but in small everyday moments when we choose our partner over secrecy, distraction, or avoidance.

“I believe you will act in my best interest, even when it’s hard.” – Dr. John Gottman

Steps to Rebuild Trust

1. End the Outside Relationship Completely

All communication with the third party must stop—no texts, emails, social media, or in-person interaction. Transparency is key to rebuilding trust.

2. Take Full Responsibility

The partner who had the affair must take ownership without defensiveness. A sincere apology acknowledges the pain caused and validates the betrayed partner’s experience.

3. Offer Transparency

Consider sharing access to phones, social media, or calendars—temporarily—to help restore a sense of safety and openness.

4. Use the ATTUNE Model to Reconnect

Rebuild emotional safety using Gottman’s ATTUNE process:

• Awareness of your partner’s emotions
• Turning Toward them, not away
• Tolerance for difficult conversations
• Understanding the story behind the hurt
• Non-defensive communication
• Empathy and presence

5. Address the Root Issues

Affairs don’t happen in strong, emotionally connected relationships. That doesn’t excuse betrayal—but it is important to explore what wasn’t working. Couples therapy can help unpack these dynamics safely.

6. Create New Rituals of Connection

Rebuilding your relationship means cultivating emotional intimacy again. This might include:

• Regular check-ins about your day
• Spending quality, distraction-free time together
• Appreciation rituals (like sharing one thing you value about each other daily)
• Planning for the future and setting goals as a team

Hope and Healing

An emotional affair is painful—but it can be the beginning of a new chapter, if both partners are willing to heal, grow, and reconnect.

If you’re navigating the aftermath of an emotional betrayal, know that you don’t have to do it alone. With guidance, support, and the right tools, it’s possible to rebuild not just trust—but a relationship that’s stronger and more emotionally secure than before.

Need support? Click here to book a confidential session .